Here are the commonly thought best Myth-only gear for levels 1, 5, 10, 15, 20, 25, 30, 35, 40, 45, and 50. Some items are in two level categories because there is no item of that level.
Any Level
- Hat: Adventurer's Helm
- Robe: Robes of the Great Troll
- Boots: Adventurer's Boots
- Pet: N/A
- Wand: Antiquated Wand
- Athame:
- Amulet: Pendant of Fangs
- Ring:
- Deck: Starter Deck
Level 5+
- Hat:
- Robe:Vestment of Eyus
- Boots:
- Pet: N/A
- Wand:Razorwire Wand
- Athame:
- Amulet: Choker of Ferocity
- Ring: Simple Peridot Ring
- Deck: Antique Deck
Level 10+
- Hat:
- Robe:
- Boots:
- Pet: N/A
- Wand:
- Athame:Shortblade of the Mirage
- Amulet: Swiftarrow's Necklace
- Ring:
- Deck: Novice Myth Deck
Level 15+
- Hat:
- Robe:
- Boots:Shoes of Figments
- Pet: N/A
- Wand:Scavenger's Staff of Sagas or Sokkwi Keymaster's Wand
- Athame:
- Amulet: Amulet of Eyes or Nebit's Locket of Whimsy
- Ring:
- Deck: Conjurer's Deck
Level 20+
- Hat: Krokenkahmen's Hat
- Robe: Krokhotep's Cloak
- Boots: Princely Shoes of Sagas
- Pet: N/A
- Wand: Scavenger's Staff of Sagas or Sokkwi Keymaster's Wand
- Athame: Amahte's Dagger of Sagas
- Amulet: Amulet of Eyes or Nebit's Locket of Whimsy
- Ring:
- Deck: Prince's Peridot Deck
Level 25+
- Hat: Victorian Hat
- Robe: Spike's Vestment of History
- Boots: Smogger's Shoes of Atlantis
- Pet: N/A
- Wand:
- Athame:
- Amulet: Old Smokey's Froggy Loop or Widow's Red Rising Amulet
- Ring:
- Deck: Enigmatic Deck
Level 30+
- Hat: Katzensteins helm
- Robe:
- Boots:Sprockets Charming boots
- Pet: N/A
- Wand: Clanker's Enigmatic Staff
- Athame:
- Amulet: Old Smokey's Froggy Loop or Widow's Red Rising Amulet
- Ring:
- Deck: Deck of the Cyclops
Level 35+
- Hat: Yakedo's Hypothetical Helm
- Robe: Yakedo's Hypothetical Robe
- Boots:Yakedo's boots
- Pet: N/A
- Wand:
- Athame:
- Amulet: Plagued Collar of the Beast
- Ring:
- Deck: Ember's Deck of Notion
Level 40+
- Hat: Jade Oni's Shroud of Nothing
- Robe: Forest Spirit's Cloak
- Boots: Plagued Boots
- Pet: N/A
- Wand: Death Oni's Peridot Blade
- Athame:
- Amulet: Plagued Collar of the Beast
- Ring:
- Deck: Jikiru's Hypothetical Deck
Level 45+
- Hat: Loremantle of the Hoarder
- Robe: Surcoat of the Homonculus
- Boots:
- Pet: N/A
- Wand:
- Athame: Kraysys' Blade of Traitors
- Amulet: Chronius' Continuum Circlet
- Ring: Dean Darkflame's Legacy Signet
- Deck: Karuvian Deck of Eternity
Level 50
- Hat: Spiderkeeper's Storyveil
- Robe: Malistaire Drake's Unhallowed Tunic
- Boots: Kraysys' Slippers of Subterfuge
- Pet: Orthrus
- Wand: epic sword
- Athame: Gurtok Mythslayer
- Amulet: Chronius' Continuum Circlet
- Ring: Philosopher's Stone
- Deck: Deck of the Silver Sentinel
Level 60
- Hat: Tricksy Cap
- Robe: Tricksy Cape
- Boots: Tricksy Boots
- Pet: Humongofrog
- Wand:
- Athame:
- Amulet:
- Ring:
- Deck: Bundle of Ananse's Stories